Eigen RadarAI
Analysis

Ontario court rejects OpenAI’s jurisdiction appeal in publishers’ lawsuit

Canada’s Ontario Court of Appeal has rejected OpenAI’s attempt to move a copyright dispute with Canadian news publishers to US courts. The decision allows the lawsuit filed in 2024 to continue in Ontario. Publishers allege their journalism was used to train models without permission or payment; the ruling addresses jurisdiction rather than the merits of those allegations.

Artificial Intelligence··Midday
Overhead view of an Ontario Court of Appeal courtroom at Osgoode Hall, Toronto: gowned lawyers gather case books and folders, with a face-down stack of folded newspapers on the publishers' table.

The lawsuit can proceed in Ontario

Canada’s Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed OpenAI’s challenge to the jurisdiction of the province’s courts in a copyright case brought by news publishers.[1], [2]

The unanimous decision leaves the lower court’s jurisdiction ruling in place and allows the case to continue. OpenAI had argued that courts in the United States were the more appropriate forum for the dispute. The appeal concerned where the case could be heard.[1], [2]

Publishers allege unauthorized model training

The plaintiffs include The Canadian Press news agency, Torstar, The Globe and Mail, Postmedia and Canada’s broadcaster CBC. They allege that OpenAI used their journalism to train models without permission or compensation. Filed in 2024, the lawsuit is described as Canada’s first copyright action over generative AI training. Whether the training was lawful and whether damages are owed remain questions for the ongoing proceedings.[1]

The appeal court considered Canadian remedies

The appeal court found no evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with US law. Its reasoning addressed foreign companies operating in Canada and the ability of Canadians alleging harm to seek a remedy at home. The earlier jurisdiction decision came from Ontario’s Superior Court, prompting OpenAI’s appeal. Friday’s decision upholds that procedural position, without determining the publishers’ copyright allegations or awarding compensation.[1]

References

  1. News sourceLa Presse / La Presse CanadienneCanadian publishers’ OpenAI lawsuit clears a jurisdiction challenge↩1↩2↩3↩4
  2. News sourceBroadcast DialogueOntario appeal ruling lets Canadian publishers pursue OpenAI case↩1↩2