Eigen RadarEconomics
Analysis

New Zealand court finds pay equity changes discriminated against women

New Zealand’s High Court ruled that the 2025 changes to pay equity law unjustifiably disadvantaged women in female-dominated occupations. The changes ended pending claims and narrowed the jobs workers can use for comparison. The court issued a declaration of inconsistency with protected rights, leaving the amended law in force.

Economics & Markets··Night
Women union representatives carrying closed case folders across the forecourt outside the High Court in Wellington, with the New Zealand Parliament complex across the street.

The court finds discrimination against women

New Zealand’s High Court found that the 2025 pay equity changes discriminated against women. Its declaration leaves the amended law in force.[1], [2]

The unions that brought the case represent workers in occupations where they say wages fall short of what the work is worth. The claim process concerns equal pay for different work of equal value. The court examined whether women in female-dominated jobs faced a disadvantage compared with workers in occupations with more men or a more balanced workforce.[1]

Workers have fewer jobs to use for comparison

Parliament adopted a pay equity framework in 2020 and tightened it in 2025. The changes ended pending claims and restricted comparisons to jobs in the same industry or sector. The law raised the threshold for a workforce to qualify as female-dominated to 70 per cent. A workforce must have met that threshold for 10 years.[1]

Parliament has a process for responding to the ruling

The court found that the closure of pending cases, tighter eligibility rules and narrower comparisons put women in female-dominated occupations at a disadvantage that the government had failed to justify under the country’s Bill of Rights Act. Parliament has a process for responding to declarations of inconsistency. In the meantime, the restrictions on claims continue to apply.[1]

References

  1. News sourceHigh Court of New ZealandNew Zealand court finds pay equity overhaul discriminated against women↩1↩2↩3↩4
  2. News sourceWellington NewsNew Zealand court finds pay equity changes breached women’s rights↩