Eigen RadarAI
Analysis

Klobuchar and Thune's AI catastrophic-risk bill stalls over liability and testing language

A bipartisan US Senate draft led by Amy Klobuchar and John Thune would place a legal duty on AI labs to mitigate catastrophic harms, but POLITICO reports the parties remain far apart and the text is not final. Nextgov/FCW reports that Maria Cantwell contests the testing framework, which would let companies self-test and present results to the Commerce secretary, while she wants mandatory vetting by national laboratories.

Artificial Intelligence··Night
An unmarked black chip under a clear case and a gavel sit before debating lawmakers in a Senate committee room.

Klobuchar-Thune draft still unfinished

Three people with knowledge of the negotiations told POLITICO that Amy Klobuchar and John Thune's catastrophic-risk bill remains unfinished, with the parties far apart on key provisions. Drafts circulated over the past week would place a legal duty on AI labs to mitigate harms from their models.[1]

Labs notify Commerce; a court can enjoin

Under the framework described to POLITICO, a lab that finds advanced capabilities must tell the Commerce Department before release, set out the mitigation and give the secretary a way to verify it. If the secretary judges a risk unaddressed, the department can seek an injunction in federal court; without one, the lab still decides whether to release, so the bill stops short of pre-approval. Drafts list risks such as helping create biological weapons or launching offensive cyber operations, and they preempt some state AI laws.[1]

Cantwell wants national-lab testing

POLITICO reports that Maria Cantwell asked for models to be tested by scientists at the national laboratories. Nextgov/FCW reports the same Cantwell objection to the Klobuchar-Thune testing framework, which with Chair Ted Cruz would let companies run safety tests and present results to the Commerce secretary; people familiar with the talks said she wants mandatory vetting by national laboratories and national security agencies. Amy Klobuchar told Nextgov/FCW she is working toward a bipartisan agreement that requires developers to work with government experts to verify and test models.[1], [2]

References

  1. News sourcePOLITICOKlobuchar and Thune's AI catastrophic-risk bill stalls over liability language↩1↩2↩3
  2. News sourceNextgov/FCWKlobuchar and Thune's AI catastrophic-risk bill faces a clash over safety testing language↩