Eigen RadarAI
Analysis

Delaware court orders personal fine for lawyer over AI filing errors

A court in the US state of Delaware ordered lawyer Richard Rollo to pay 2,500 dollars personally after an AI-assisted filing contained invented quotations and inaccurate legal propositions. The November 13 decision leaves his firm unsanctioned, citing its preventive policies and training, while holding the signing lawyer responsible for checking the authorities.

Artificial Intelligence··Evening
A spiral-bound court filing heavily marked in red ink lies on a walnut table in a Delaware law firm room beside plain cloth-bound books, evoking a lawyer's duty to verify citations.

Rollo must pay the court himself

A lawyer in the US state of Delaware must personally pay 2,500 dollars after submitting an AI-assisted filing containing invented quotations and distorted descriptions of legal decisions. In her November 13 ruling, Court of Chancery judge Lori W. Will gave Richard Rollo 14 days to pay and required a sworn statement confirming payment. The sanction follows his eventual acceptance of responsibility for the errors. The court considered his remorse when setting the amount.[1]

The firm’s safeguards avert a separate sanction

The single court decision distinguishes the lawyer’s conduct from the precautions his firm had already adopted. Richards, Layton & Finger avoided a sanction because its rules restricted unapproved tools, required experienced lawyers to review AI output and provided mandatory ethics training. Rollo said he had used Perplexity Enterprise, an AI research service being evaluated in a pilot rather than approved for general use at the firm. He assigned citation checks to a junior lawyer and a paralegal.[1]

Removing quotation marks left the errors intact

The disputed filing was submitted for the plaintiffs on January 22 in litigation involving Kevin Leiske and Robert Gregory Kidd. Defendants identified the errors, prompting a revision that removed quotation marks but kept false accounts of what the cases established. Will held that the signing lawyer’s duty to verify legal authorities cannot be delegated. Her decision permits generative AI in legal work while applying existing verification obligations to quotations, citations and legal propositions.[1]

References

  1. News sourceDelaware Court of ChanceryDelaware court fines lawyer over errors in an AI-assisted brief↩1↩2↩3