Van Gogh sale proceeds after settlement with Fischer heirs
The owners of Van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs have reached an agreement with the Fischer heirs before its planned New York auction on November 18. Sotheby’s says the settlement resolves ownership claims. The heirs had challenged the family’s Nazi-era sale of the painting; the financial terms of the new agreement remain private.
Arts··Night
An agreement precedes the New York auction
Sotheby’s, the auction house organising the New York sale of Vincent van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs, has announced a settlement between the painting’s owners and the Fischer heirs. The Blaquier-Arrieta family reached the agreement with all legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer before the planned November 18 auction. The current owners have held the painting since 1975.[1], [2]
Sotheby’s told ARTnews that the agreement resolves the ownership claims and that the buyer will receive clear title. The financial terms were not disclosed, including whether the heirs will receive compensation. The 1890 painting carries a presale estimate of 180 million dollars, a forecast made before the work has gone under the hammer.[1]
The heirs challenged the conditions of the 1936 sale
The Fischer heirs argued that Nazi persecution and the resulting financial pressures had forced the Jewish publishing family to sell the painting in Amsterdam in 1936. Their Berlin-based lawyer Gunnar Schnabel sought its withdrawal from auction unless Sotheby’s could establish that the earlier transaction had been voluntary. The dispute concerned the circumstances in which the family parted with the work.[1]
Sotheby’s disputed that account, citing records in art dealer Paul Cassirer’s archives. The auction house said the picture sold through Cassirer in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs, which it described as a fair price. It also said the family had already been in Amsterdam for three years. The settlement does not decide whether that sale took place under duress.[1]
The family’s restitution efforts enter the settlement
The heirs welcomed recognition of their family’s suffering under the Nazis and the restitution efforts of Gisela Bermann-Fischer, who died in 2014. In 2007 she had allowed a Cézanne painting to be sold while expressly reserving the right to challenge other transactions involving the family’s art. Sotheby’s said the new agreement acknowledges the Fischer family’s persecution as well as the Van Gogh painting’s complicated history.[1]