Eigen RadarEconomics
Analysis

Britain will weigh public purchases against leases for new trains

Britain’s new rail strategy directs Great British Railways to compare direct public ownership, leasing and other financing for each future train order. Existing leases remain in force, but renting will cease to be the automatic choice for new rolling stock. The government cites more than £4 billion in annual leasing and maintenance costs; that total does not establish whether any specific purchase would save money. Each procurement will need its own value assessment.

Economics & Markets··Midday
Rail workers inspect a passenger train inside a maintenance hall

Public purchase becomes an option

Britain’s rail strategy directs Great British Railways, the body being set up to coordinate the national network, to compare direct public ownership with leasing and other financing for each future train order. Existing leases will continue, while leasing will no longer be the automatic starting point for new vehicles. The government has opened a procurement choice; it has not announced a blanket purchase of all trains now on lease.[1], [2]

Annual leasing costs frame the decision

Passenger trains have mostly belonged to rolling-stock companies and been leased to operators for more than three decades. The Department for Transport says leasing and maintenance cost passengers and taxpayers more than £4 billion a year. It also cites over £2.5 billion in dividends paid by train-owning companies over the past decade. Neither aggregate figure shows that outright purchase would be cheaper for a particular train order; the strategy calls for a separate value comparison in each case.[1]

Procurement joins a wider rail plan

The strategy asks Great British Railways to plan trains together with tracks, depots and maintenance, instead of treating each investment in isolation. It also proposes more standardised train families so vehicles can be used more flexibly across the network. The department expects battery-powered trains to play a part as diesel fleets are replaced. Those planning goals accompany the financing change, but the policy leaves the ownership method for each future order open until its specific assessment.[1]

References

  1. News sourceDepartment for TransportBritain to assess public purchases rather than leasing for new trains↩1↩2↩3
  2. News sourceRailBusinessDailyNew UK trains could be publicly owned under Great British Railways↩