The scope of the weight-gain benefit

Supporting appropriate weight gain in pregnancy takes more work than repeating a target at each visit. In the randomized trial in Babol, Iran, 188 women received routine care or additional counselling. Excessive gain occurred in 23.4 per cent of the counselling group and 40.4 per cent of controls: an absolute difference of 17.0 percentage points. This points to a tangible benefit from structured support in a defined patient group.[1]

The mean difference in weight gain by delivery was 1.56 kg. Caesarean delivery, birth weight, gestational age and neonatal intensive-care admission showed no significant differences. The trial was not sized to test these outcomes reliably. Improved weight gain therefore has value, while the size of any benefit for more consequential maternal and infant outcomes remains uncertain.[1]

The person delivering the care

The human work in this programme deserves to remain visible. Each of 3 in-person sessions lasted 45–50 minutes, and each of 3 video sessions lasted 15–20 minutes. Educational materials were followed by telephone contact. A trained midwifery-counselling student delivered sessions under weekly supervision. There is no evidence here for expecting the same effect from the app separated from that support.[1]

For me, the central implementation question is how routine care can accommodate that counselling time. The experiment combined motivational interviewing, lifestyle counselling and educational materials. Additional attention and contact may also have contributed. Since individual contributions were not separated, costing the intervention requires accounting for the entire care package; the trial did not measure cost-effectiveness.[1]

Who can reach the support?

Participants had pre-pregnancy body mass index of 18.5–24.9 kg/m² and all had smartphone access. These boundaries leave the benefit unestablished for women entering pregnancy with overweight or without digital access. Findings from 2 hospitals in one city require separate assessment when applied to different income and care settings.[1]

Follow-up was completed by 88 intervention participants and 83 controls, with missing data handled in an intention-to-treat analysis. Differing attrition and short postpartum follow-up nevertheless leave uncertainty. The patient value of this counselling rests on assessing accessible contact time alongside longer-term maternal and infant outcomes. Owning a phone is only one condition for reaching that support.[1]