Inside the prize label
Your Breath in Charcoal, in its English edition from Goose Lane Editions, now carries the Giller Prize label. Nine independent booksellers from across Canada selected Nicholas Herring’s second novel. This is the first Giller jury composed entirely of booksellers. Placing that group beside the edition gives the reader a concrete account of the invitation: a particular set of readers has chosen this particular book. Their occupation becomes part of the frame through which the novel is encountered.[1]
The selection moved from more than 140 submissions to a longlist of 14, then five finalists and a winner. A single outcome cannot tell us which aesthetic preferences bookselling experience brought to the process. The more useful opening is the jury’s description of the novel. It turns the award label into a literary proposition that can be discussed, giving the reader something more precise to consider when choosing where to begin.[1]
The judges describe Knickle’s journey from Prince Edward Island to Toronto around his distinctive voice, linking popular culture, literary allusion and philosophical reflection. The emphasis on voice interests me more than the route itself. A reader entering through that doorway can follow how Knickle puts the world into words as well as where he travels. The sentences provide the place to test the judges’ description against an encounter with the novel.[1]
Room for the reader’s question
That invitation offers a focus for attention rather than a ready-made verdict. One might ask when Knickle reaches for an allusion, where a conversation leaves him silent, or how movement interrupts reflection. These are questions to bring to the text, not descriptions of scenes I am claiming to have read. Beginning with them leaves room for disagreement with the prize while sustaining interest in the novel’s actual language.[1]
The scheduled discussions give readers places to share those questions: Ian Williams is due to speak with Herring at Toronto’s Book Bar on November 17, followed by Mark Medley at Toronto Reference Library on November 18. A question first prompted by the jury can meet the author’s account there. For a reader, the useful conversation would open up how the novel’s voice was made. That is a more specific ambition than extending the celebration.[1]
Herring’s two-week writing residency at Banff gives the prize another dimension: time set aside for the writer’s work. Public discussion and a private place to write serve different purposes. Returning to the Goose Lane edition, both remain around the book; the relationship with Knickle’s voice must still be made by reading. The best doorway the prize opens leads there, allowing a reader to know who made the selection while carrying an independent question into the sentences.[1]