The arithmetic of looking for work

UK unemployment falling to 4.6% is welcome news. At the same time, the openings facing someone looking for work are narrowing: vacancies have fallen to 690,000. Those movements raise a distributional question about where improvement begins. Someone already employed and someone trying to enter work encounter the same labour market from different positions. I put particular weight on the opportunities available to the second group. A lower unemployment rate coexists with fewer advertised openings.[1]

The contraction has an identifiable location. Vacancies fell by 22,000 between the rolling quarters. The decline at businesses employing one to nine people was also 22,000. On these rounded figures, the smallest businesses account for a reduction equal to the aggregate net loss. Their remaining 73,000 vacancies were the lowest outside the pandemic since spring 2012. For someone entering employment or seeking another job, the opening offered by small employers has narrowed appreciably.[1]

People already on the payroll

People already employed are not enjoying broad relief either. Annual regular-pay growth in Great Britain slowed to 3.5%. After inflation including housing costs, the gain was 0.2%. That small real increase describes average pay and purchasing power; individual workers receive different increases. Nominal growth was 5.4% in the public sector and 3.1% in the private sector. Even that difference between sector averages shows the limits of describing one common experience for employees.[1]

Payroll employment matters alongside vacancies. Its July–September average was 32,000 below the preceding quarter. The first October estimate shows a monthly fall of 34,000 and remains subject to revision. Both payroll comparisons point to fewer employees. A modest increase in average real regular pay sits alongside a decline in the number receiving a payroll income. Average earnings per employee and the number of employees reach households through different channels.[1]

The breadth of improvement

The labour-force survey contains a more encouraging side: employment among 16–64-year-olds reached 75.4%, while inactivity fell to 20.8%. That movement deserves recognition. The statistics office also says the characteristics of incoming and outgoing survey groups contributed to the unemployment decline. Payroll statistics and the labour-force survey cover different populations as well. Substituting one movement for the other can therefore give an overly reassuring account of the position facing people seeking work. Coverage differences may explain part of the divergence; actual employment changes and the characteristics of incoming survey groups may also contribute.[1]

My yardstick places the purchasing power of current employees alongside the vacancies facing people trying to enter work. This release shows a limited gain in the former and a contraction in the latter. Small businesses’ decline, equal to the aggregate net vacancy loss, makes that distinction tangible. More openings at small employers and an increase in employee numbers are relevant measures of a recovery reaching more people. Today’s figures give reason to acknowledge lower unemployment while keeping the narrowing route into work in view.[1]