From dance to conversation
Johann Strauss II’s Die Fledermaus overture, then Mozart’s Piano Concerto No 25 in C major. Manfred Honeck and Emanuel Ax’s programme at London’s Royal Festival Hall on 12 November establishes two different kinds of movement at the outset. The overture brings the collective flow of a dance; the concerto places a soloist in conversation with the orchestra. That sequence offers a useful way to consider the Philharmonia’s principal conductor designate: a programme choice that makes room both for ensemble movement and for an individual player.[1]
Guardian critic Alexandra Coghlan praises the delayed final beats of the overture’s bars and its woodwind playing. In Ax’s Mozart, she singles out exchanges with flute and oboe in the slow movement and the differentiated episodes of the final rondo. These are the reviewer’s observations about the performance. Read alongside the programme, they create a concrete comparison: the orchestra shapes the timing of a dance in one work and gives definition to the voices answering a pianist in another. Those relationships are a useful focus for considering the conductor’s role.[1]
Mozart’s position between the two Strausses may turn a listener’s attention from broad orchestral movement to smaller encounters. That is an interpretation of the programme. A simpler explanation is also possible: the choice may follow the familiar concert pattern of framing a recognised concerto with contrasting orchestral works. Even so, Ax’s place matters. The concerto occupies the centre of the list while opening a question about how an individual voice and an ensemble work alongside one another.[1]
The weight of opera within the orchestra
The final work is Honeck’s suite from Richard Strauss’s Elektra. The programme therefore travels from Johann Strauss II’s ballroom world to an opera’s intense family conflict. Coghlan highlights cymbals and brass in the heroine’s triumphal dance and the strings at the dramatic climax. The contrast she describes is also legible in the named works: the opening overture and closing operatic suite put dance to different dramatic uses. A related idea of movement acquires a different weight at either end of the programme.[1]
The arrangement is a tangible part of the conductor’s relationship with repertoire. Turning Elektra into a suite places operatic material within this concert’s orchestral forces and sequence. In Ax’s concerto, a piano faces the ensemble; in the finale, dramatic weight moves among orchestral instruments. That difference gives substance to Honeck’s stated attachment to tradition. The attachment becomes audible through the form in which works are played and the neighbours they are given within a programme.[1]
Honeck’s Philharmonia tenure is scheduled to begin in 2028. This evening can be considered on its own terms. Its three works leave a concrete programme: a collectively shaped dance, a conversation with a soloist and dramatic tension moved from opera into an orchestral suite. They give listeners a productive question about the designated conductor. How clearly does the same ensemble carry these different tasks? The useful point of reference is who plays in each work and how room is made for the other voices.[1]